LEADING QUESTIONS AND THE MIRANDA RIGHT

1. During a criminal interrogation can you suggest that you will only answer appropriate questions? Yes, you can clarify that you will only answer questions that are fair and appropriate, and avoid those that may lead to speculation or misinterpretation. Being calm and respectful when setting these boundaries is important.

2. Can you record the interview with your phone for future reference? The ability to record an interview depends on the laws of your jurisdiction. In some places, it is legal to record conversations if at least one party (you) consents, while other areas require the consent of all parties. In Colombia, recording can generally be permissible for personal use, but you should verify local regulations and consider informing the officers to avoid potential legal complications.

3. Can you have a notebook to write down the names of the interviewing officers? Yes, taking notes, including the names of the officers present, is generally acceptable and can be a good practice to document important details about the interview. It demonstrates your intent to keep an accurate record.

4. Can you ask the officers why they suspect you and request evidence? Yes, you may ask officers why they suspect you and whether they have evidence supporting their suspicion. However, officers may not be required to disclose this information to you, especially during an ongoing investigation. They might offer general statements but could withhold specific evidence.

Here are some examples of questions that may be considered inappropriate or could lead to misinterpretation during an interrogation:

1. Ambiguous or Vague Questions:

   • "Where were you last night?" (without specifying a time frame or context).

   • "Why do you think you look guilty?"

   These can cause confusion due to a lack of clarity and could be misconstrued depending on how you respond.

2. Speculative Questions:

   • "What do you think happened to the victim?"

   • "How would you have committed this crime if you were the criminal?"

   These might imply involvement or create misleading inferences based on your answers.

3. Leading or Loaded Questions:

   • "You were at the scene of the crime, weren't you?"

   • "Why did you take the item?"

   These suggest a presumption of guilt and frame the question in a way that may make it difficult to respond without implying guilt.

4. Emotionally Charged Questions:

   • "Don't you feel bad about what you did?"

   • "How could someone do such a thing and sleep at night?"

   These are designed to provoke emotional reactions and may not be directly relevant to the facts of the case.

5. Inconsistent or Contradictory Questions:

   • Asking the same question in different ways to catch you in a slip-up (e.g., "What time did you leave?" followed by "What time did you arrive?").

It's a good idea to remain calm and ask for clarification when faced with vague or ambiguous questions. You’re also within your rights to request legal representation to guide you through the process. Let me know if you'd like further guidance on handling situations like this!

To object to inappropriate or potentially misleading questions during a criminal interrogation, you can use calm, clear, and respectful language. Here are some ways to handle each type of question:

1. Ambiguous or Vague Questions:

   • Say: "Can you clarify the time or context of your question? I want to ensure I understand it fully before responding."

2. Speculative Questions:

   • Say: "I’m sorry, but I can’t answer hypothetical or speculative questions. I would prefer to stick to facts."

3. Leading or Loaded Questions:

   • Say: "I feel that question assumes something I haven’t stated. I’d prefer not to answer based on that assumption."

4. Emotionally Charged Questions:

   • Say: "I understand the seriousness of this situation, but I’d like to keep this conversation focused on facts."

5. Inconsistent or Contradictory Questions:

   • Say: "It seems that this question has already been asked in a different way. Could you clarify what additional information you’re seeking?"

Additionally, you can emphasize your rights by saying something like, "I want to ensure I answer accurately and appropriately, so I’d prefer to have legal counsel present before continuing."

The key is to stay polite and composed—remaining calm can go a long way in maintaining control of the situation. Would you like help drafting a script for any specific scenario?

********************************************************